Over the years, the award has gone through some minor changes. After the first year's awards were given out irrespective of league, in 1958, Gold Gloves were awarded in each league. Starting in 1961, voters picked any three outfielders rather than one at each outfield position.
The award itself is a gold lamé-tanned leather glove affixed to a walnut base.
| Year | Pitcher | Catcher | First Baseman | Second Baseman | Third Baseman | Shortstop | Outfielder | Outfielder | Outfielder
|
| 1958
| Bobby Shantz New York Yankees
| Sherm Lollar Chicago White Sox
| Vic Power Kansas City Athletics/ Cleveland Indians
| Frank Bolling Detroit Tigers
| Frank Malzone Boston Red Sox
| Luis Aparicio Chicago White Sox
| Norm Siebern (LF) New York Yankees
| Jimmy Piersall (CF) Boston Red Sox
| Al Kaline (RF) Detroit Tigers
|
| 1959
| Bobby Shantz New York Yankees
| Sherm Lollar Chicago White Sox
| Vic Power Cleveland Indians
| Nellie Fox Chicago White Sox
| Frank Malzone Boston Red Sox
| Luis Aparicio Chicago White Sox
| Minnie Minoso (LF) Cleveland Indians
| Al Kaline (CF) Detroit Tigers
| Jackie Jensen (RF) Boston Red Sox
|
| 1960
| Bobby Shantz New York Yankees
| Earl Battey Washington Senators
| Vic Power Cleveland Indians
| Nellie Fox Chicago White Sox
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Luis Aparicio Chicago White Sox
| Minnie Minoso (LF) Chicago White Sox
| Jim Landis (CF) Chicago White Sox
| Roger Maris (RF) New York Yankees
|
| 1961
| Frank Lary Detroit Tigers
| Earl Battey Minnesota Twins
| Vic Power Cleveland Indians
| Bobby Richardson New York Yankees
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Luis Aparicio Chicago White Sox
| Jimmy Piersall Cleveland Indians
| Jim Landis Chicago White Sox
| Al Kaline Detroit Tigers
|
| 1962
| Jim Kaat Minnesota Twins
| Earl Battey Minnesota Twins
| Vic Power Minnesota Twins
| Bobby Richardson New York Yankees
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Luis Aparicio Chicago White Sox
| Mickey Mantle New York Yankees
| Jim Landis Chicago White Sox
| Al Kaline Detroit Tigers
|
| 1963
| Jim Kaat Minnesota Twins
| Elston Howard New York Yankees
| Vic Power Minnesota Twins
| Bobby Richardson New York Yankees
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Zoilo Versalles Minnesota Twins
| Carl Yastrzemski Boston Red Sox
| Jim Landis Chicago White Sox
| Al Kaline Detroit Tigers
|
| 1964
| Jim Kaat Minnesota Twins
| Elston Howard New York Yankees
| Vic Power Minnesota Twins/ Los Angeles Angels/ Philadelphia Phillies
| Bobby Richardson New York Yankees
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Luis Aparicio Baltimore Orioles
| Vic Davalillo Cleveland Indians
| Jim Landis Chicago White Sox
| Al Kaline Detroit Tigers
|
| 1965
| Jim Kaat Minnesota Twins
| Bill Freehan Detroit Tigers
| Joe Pepitone New York Yankees
| Bobby Richardson New York Yankees
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Zoilo Versalles Minnesota Twins
| Tom Tresh New York Yankees
| Carl Yastrzemski Boston Red Sox
| Al Kaline Detroit Tigers
|
| 1966
| Jim Kaat Minnesota Twins
| Bill Freehan Detroit Tigers
| Joe Pepitone New York Yankees
| Bobby Knoop California Angels
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Luis Aparicio Baltimore Orioles
| Tommie Agee Chicago White Sox
| Tony Oliva Minnesota Twins
| Al Kaline Detroit Tigers
|
| 1967
| Jim Kaat Minnesota Twins
| Bill Freehan Detroit Tigers
| George Scott Boston Red Sox
| Bobby Knoop California Angels
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Jim Fregosi California Angels
| Carl Yastrzemski Boston Red Sox
| Paul Blair Baltimore Orioles
| Al Kaline Detroit Tigers
|
| 1968
| Jim Kaat Minnesota Twins
| Bill Freehan Detroit Tigers
| George Scott Boston Red Sox
| Bobby Knoop California Angels
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Luis Aparicio Chicago White Sox
| Carl Yastrzemski Boston Red Sox
| Reggie Smith Boston Red Sox
| Mickey Stanley Detroit Tigers
|
| 1969
| Jim Kaat Minnesota Twins
| Bill Freehan Detroit Tigers
| Joe Pepitone New York Yankees
| Davey Johnson Baltimore Orioles
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Mark Belanger Baltimore Orioles
| Carl Yastrzemski Boston Red Sox
| Paul Blair Baltimore Orioles
| Mickey Stanley Detroit Tigers
|
| 1970
| Jim Kaat Minnesota Twins
| Ray Fosse Cleveland Indians
| Jim Spencer California Angels
| Davey Johnson Baltimore Orioles
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Luis Aparicio Chicago White Sox
| Ken Berry Chicago White Sox
| Paul Blair Baltimore Orioles
| Mickey Stanley Detroit Tigers
|
| 1971
| Jim Kaat Minnesota Twins
| Ray Fosse Cleveland Indians
| George Scott Boston Red Sox
| Davey Johnson Baltimore Orioles
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Mark Belanger Baltimore Orioles
| Amos Otis Kansas City Royals
| Paul Blair Baltimore Orioles
| Carl Yastrzemski Boston Red Sox
|
| 1972
| Jim Kaat Minnesota Twins
| Carlton Fisk Boston Red Sox
| George Scott Milwaukee Brewers
| Doug Griffin Boston Red Sox
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Ed Brinkman Detroit Tigers
| Ken Berry California Angels
| Paul Blair Baltimore Orioles
| Bobby Murcer New York Yankees
|
| 1973
| Jim Kaat Minnesota Twins/ Chicago White Sox
| Thurman Munson New York Yankees
| George Scott Milwaukee Brewers
| Bobby Grich Baltimore Orioles
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Mark Belanger Baltimore Orioles
| Amos Otis Kansas City Royals
| Paul Blair Baltimore Orioles
| Mickey Stanley Detroit Tigers
|
| 1974
| Jim Kaat Chicago White Sox
| Thurman Munson New York Yankees
| George Scott Milwaukee Brewers
| Bobby Grich Baltimore Orioles
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Mark Belanger Baltimore Orioles
| Amos Otis Kansas City Royals
| Paul Blair Baltimore Orioles
| Joe Rudi Oakland Athletics
|
| 1975
| Jim Kaat Chicago White Sox
| Thurman Munson New York Yankees
| George Scott Milwaukee Brewers
| Bobby Grich Baltimore Orioles
| Brooks Robinson Baltimore Orioles
| Mark Belanger Baltimore Orioles
| Fred Lynn Boston Red Sox
| Paul Blair Baltimore Orioles
| Joe Rudi Oakland Athletics
|
| 1976
| Jim Palmer Baltimore Orioles
| Jim Sundberg Texas Rangers
| George Scott Milwaukee Brewers
| Bobby Grich Baltimore Orioles
| Aurelio Rodríguez Detroit Tigers
| Mark Belanger Baltimore Orioles
| Dwight Evans Boston Red Sox
| Rick Manning Cleveland Indians
| Joe Rudi Oakland Athletics
|
| 1977
| Jim Palmer Baltimore Orioles
| Jim Sundberg Texas Rangers
| Jim Spencer Chicago White Sox
| Frank White Kansas City Royals
| Graig Nettles New York Yankees
| Mark Belanger Baltimore Orioles
| Carl Yastrzemski Boston Red Sox
| Juan Beniquez Texas Rangers
| Al Cowens Kansas City Royals
|
| 1978
| Jim Palmer Baltimore Orioles
| Jim Sundberg Texas Rangers
| Chris Chambliss New York Yankees
| Frank White Kansas City Royals
| Graig Nettles New York Yankees
| Mark Belanger Baltimore Orioles
| Dwight Evans Boston Red Sox
| Rick Miller California Angels
| Fred Lynn Boston Red Sox
|
| 1979
| Jim Palmer Baltimore Orioles
| Jim Sundberg Texas Rangers
| Cecil Cooper Milwaukee Brewers
| Frank White Kansas City Royals
| Buddy Bell Texas Rangers
| Rick Burleson Boston Red Sox
| Dwight Evans Boston Red Sox
| Sixto Lezcano Milwaukee Brewers
| Fred Lynn Boston Red Sox
|
| 1980
| Mike Norris Oakland Athletics
| Jim Sundberg Texas Rangers
| Cecil Cooper Milwaukee Brewers
| Frank White Kansas City Royals
| Buddy Bell Texas Rangers
| Alan Trammell Detroit Tigers
| Fred Lynn Boston Red Sox
| Dwayne Murphy Oakland Athletics
| Willie Wilson Kansas City Royals
|
| 1981
| Mike Norris Oakland Athletics
| Jim Sundberg Texas Rangers
| Mike Squires Chicago White Sox
| Frank White Kansas City Royals
| Buddy Bell Texas Rangers
| Alan Trammell Detroit Tigers
| Dwayne Murphy Oakland Athletics
| Dwight Evans Boston Red Sox
| Rickey Henderson Oakland Athletics
|
| 1982
| Ron Guidry New York Yankees
| Bob Boone California Angels
| Eddie Murray Baltimore Orioles
| Frank White Kansas City Royals
| Buddy Bell Texas Rangers
| Robin Yount Milwaukee Brewers
| Dwight Evans Boston Red Sox
| Dave Winfield New York Yankees
| Dwayne Murphy Oakland Athletics
|
| 1983
| Ron Guidry New York Yankees
| Lance Parrish Detroit Tigers
| Eddie Murray Baltimore Orioles
| Lou Whitaker Detroit Tigers
| Buddy Bell Texas Rangers
| Alan Trammell Detroit Tigers
| Dwight Evans Boston Red Sox
| Dave Winfield New York Yankees
| Dwayne Murphy Oakland Athletics
|
| 1984
| Ron Guidry New York Yankees
| Lance Parrish Detroit Tigers
| Eddie Murray Baltimore Orioles
| Lou Whitaker Detroit Tigers
| Buddy Bell Texas Rangers
| Alan Trammell Detroit Tigers
| Dwight Evans Boston Red Sox
| Dave Winfield New York Yankees
| Dwayne Murphy Oakland Athletics
|
| 1985
| Ron Guidry New York Yankees
| Lance Parrish Detroit Tigers
| Don Mattingly New York Yankees
| Lou Whitaker Detroit Tigers
| George Brett Kansas City Royals
| Alfredo Griffin Oakland Athletics
| Gary Pettis California Angels
| Dave Winfield New York Yankees
| Dwayne Murphy / Dwight Evans Oakland Athletics / Boston Red Sox
|
| 1986
| Ron Guidry New York Yankees
| Bob Boone California Angels
| Don Mattingly New York Yankees
| Frank White Kansas City Royals
| Gary Gaetti Minnesota Twins
| Tony Fernandez Toronto Blue Jays
| Jesse Barfield Toronto Blue Jays
| Kirby Puckett Minnesota Twins
| Gary Pettis California Angels
|
| 1987
| Mark Langston Seattle Mariners
| Bob Boone California Angels
| Don Mattingly New York Yankees
| Frank White Kansas City Royals
| Gary Gaetti Minnesota Twins
| Tony Fernandez Toronto Blue Jays
| Jesse Barfield Toronto Blue Jays
| Kirby Puckett Minnesota Twins
| Dave Winfield New York Yankees
|
| 1988
| Mark Langston Seattle Mariners
| Bob Boone California Angels
| Don Mattingly New York Yankees
| Harold Reynolds Seattle Mariners
| Gary Gaetti Minnesota Twins
| Tony Fernandez Toronto Blue Jays
| Devon White California Angels
| Gary Pettis California Angels
| Kirby Puckett Minnesota Twins
|
| 1989
| Bret Saberhagen Kansas City Royals
| Bob Boone Kansas City Royals
| Don Mattingly New York Yankees
| Harold Reynolds Seattle Mariners
| Gary Gaetti Minnesota Twins
| Tony Fernandez Toronto Blue Jays
| Gary Pettis Detroit Tigers
| Kirby Puckett Minnesota Twins
| Devon White California Angels
|
| 1990
| Mike Boddicker Boston Red Sox
| Sandy Alomar, Jr. Cleveland Indians
| Mark McGwire Oakland Athletics
| Harold Reynolds Seattle Mariners
| Kelly Gruber Toronto Blue Jays
| Ozzie Guillen Chicago White Sox
| Ellis Burks Boston Red Sox
| Ken Griffey, Jr. Seattle Mariners
| Gary Pettis Texas Rangers
|
| 1991
| Mark Langston California Angels
| Tony Peña Boston Red Sox
| Don Mattingly New York Yankees
| Roberto Alomar Toronto Blue Jays
| Robin Ventura Chicago White Sox
| Cal Ripken, Jr. Baltimore Orioles
| Ken Griffey, Jr. Seattle Mariners
| Devon White Toronto Blue Jays
| Kirby Puckett Minnesota Twins
|
| 1992
| Mark Langston California Angels
| Ivan Rodriguez Texas Rangers
| Don Mattingly New York Yankees
| Roberto Alomar Toronto Blue Jays
| Robin Ventura Chicago White Sox
| Cal Ripken, Jr. Baltimore Orioles
| Ken Griffey, Jr. Seattle Mariners
| Devon White Toronto Blue Jays
| Kirby Puckett Minnesota Twins
|
| 1993
| Mark Langston California Angels
| Ivan Rodriguez Texas Rangers
| Don Mattingly New York Yankees
| Roberto Alomar Toronto Blue Jays
| Robin Ventura Chicago White Sox
| Omar Vizquel Seattle Mariners
| Ken Griffey, Jr. Seattle Mariners
| Kenny Lofton Cleveland Indians
| Devon White Toronto Blue Jays
|
| 1994
| Mark Langston California Angels
| Ivan Rodriguez Texas Rangers
| Don Mattingly New York Yankees
| Roberto Alomar Toronto Blue Jays
| Wade Boggs New York Yankees
| Omar Vizquel Cleveland Indians
| Ken Griffey, Jr. Seattle Mariners
| Kenny Lofton Cleveland Indians
| Devon White Toronto Blue Jays
|
| 1995
| Mark Langston California Angels
| Ivan Rodriguez Texas Rangers
| J.T. Snow California Angels
| Roberto Alomar Toronto Blue Jays
| Wade Boggs New York Yankees
| Omar Vizquel Cleveland Indians
| Ken Griffey, Jr. Seattle Mariners
| Kenny Lofton Cleveland Indians
| Devon White Toronto Blue Jays
|
| 1996
| Mike Mussina Baltimore Orioles
| Ivan Rodriguez Texas Rangers
| J.T. Snow California Angels
| Roberto Alomar Baltimore Orioles
| Robin Ventura Chicago White Sox
| Omar Vizquel Cleveland Indians
| Ken Griffey, Jr. Seattle Mariners
| Kenny Lofton Cleveland Indians
| Jay Buhner Seattle Mariners
|
| 1997
| Mike Mussina Baltimore Orioles
| Ivan Rodriguez Texas Rangers
| Rafael Palmeiro Baltimore Orioles
| Chuck Knoblauch Minnesota Twins
| Matt Williams Cleveland Indians
| Omar Vizquel Cleveland Indians
| Ken Griffey, Jr. Seattle Mariners
| Jim Edmonds Anaheim Angels
| Bernie Williams New York Yankees
|
| 1998
| Mike Mussina Baltimore Orioles
| Ivan Rodriguez Texas Rangers
| Rafael Palmeiro Baltimore Orioles
| Roberto Alomar Baltimore Orioles
| Robin Ventura Chicago White Sox
| Omar Vizquel Cleveland Indians
| Ken Griffey, Jr. Seattle Mariners
| Bernie Williams New York Yankees
| Jim Edmonds Anaheim Angels
|
| 1999
| Mike Mussina Baltimore Orioles
| Ivan Rodriguez Texas Rangers
| Rafael Palmeiro Texas Rangers
| Roberto Alomar Cleveland Indians
| Scott Brosius New York Yankees
| Omar Vizquel Cleveland Indians
| Ken Griffey, Jr. Seattle Mariners
| Bernie Williams New York Yankees
| Shawn Green Toronto Blue Jays
|
| 2000
| Kenny Rogers Texas Rangers
| Ivan Rodriguez Texas Rangers
| John Olerud Seattle Mariners
| Roberto Alomar Cleveland Indians
| Travis Fryman Cleveland Indians
| Omar Vizquel Cleveland Indians
| Darin Erstad Anaheim Angels
| Bernie Williams New York Yankees
| Jermaine Dye Kansas City Royals
|
| 2001
| Mike Mussina New York Yankees
| Ivan Rodriguez Texas Rangers
| Doug Mientkiewicz Minnesota Twins
| Roberto Alomar Cleveland Indians
| Eric Chavez Oakland Athletics
| Omar Vizquel Cleveland Indians
| Mike Cameron Seattle Mariners
| Torii Hunter Minnesota Twins
| Ichiro Suzuki Seattle Mariners
|
| 2002
| Kenny Rogers Texas Rangers
| Bengie Molina Anaheim Angels
| John Olerud Seattle Mariners
| Bret Boone Seattle Mariners
| Eric Chavez Oakland Athletics
| Alex Rodriguez Texas Rangers
| Torii Hunter Minnesota Twins
| Darin Erstad Anaheim Angels
| Ichiro Suzuki Seattle Mariners
|
| 2003
| Mike Mussina New York Yankees
| Bengie Molina Anaheim Angels
| John Olerud Seattle Mariners
| Bret Boone Seattle Mariners
| Eric Chavez Oakland Athletics
| Alex Rodriguez Texas Rangers
| Mike Cameron Seattle Mariners
| Torii Hunter Minnesota Twins
| Ichiro Suzuki Seattle Mariners
|
| 2004
| Kenny Rogers Texas Rangers
| Ivan Rodriguez Detroit Tigers
| Darin Erstad Anaheim Angels
| Bret Boone Seattle Mariners
| Eric Chavez Oakland Athletics
| Derek Jeter New York Yankees
| Torii Hunter Minnesota Twins
| Ichiro Suzuki Seattle Mariners
| Vernon Wells Toronto Blue Jays
|
| 2005
| Kenny Rogers Texas Rangers
| Jason Varitek Boston Red Sox
| Mark Teixeira Texas Rangers
| Orlando Hudson Toronto Blue Jays
| Eric Chavez Oakland Athletics
| Derek Jeter New York Yankees
| Torii Hunter Minnesota Twins
| Ichiro Suzuki Seattle Mariners
| Vernon Wells Toronto Blue Jays
|
| 2006
| Kenny Rogers Detroit Tigers
| Ivan Rodriguez Detroit Tigers
| Mark Teixeira Texas Rangers
| Mark Grudzielanek Kansas City Royals
| Eric Chavez Oakland Athletics
| Derek Jeter New York Yankees
| Torii Hunter Minnesota Twins
| Ichiro Suzuki Seattle Mariners
| Vernon Wells Toronto Blue Jays
|
| 2007
| Johan Santana Minnesota Twins
| Ivan Rodriguez Detroit Tigers
| Kevin Youkilis Boston Red Sox
| Placido Polanco Detroit Tigers
| Adrian Beltre Seattle Mariners
| Orlando Cabrera Los Angeles Angels
| Torii Hunter Minnesota Twins
| Grady Sizemore Cleveland Indians
| Ichiro Suzuki Seattle Mariners
|
| 2008
| Mike Mussina New York Yankees
| Joe Mauer Minnesota Twins
| Carlos Pena Tampa Bay Rays
| Dustin Pedroia Boston Red Sox
| Adrian Beltre Seattle Mariners
| Michael Young Texas Rangers
| Torii Hunter Los Angeles Angels
| Grady Sizemore Cleveland Indians
| Ichiro Suzuki Seattle Mariners
|