Spanning Multiple Seasons or entire Careers, From 1901 to 2008, (requiring HR≥240 and HR≤250), sorted by smallest RBI

  Cnt Player             **RBI**  HR From  To   Ages   G    PA    AB    R    H   2B  3B  BB  IBB  SO  HBP  SH  SF GDP  SB   CS   BA   OBP   SLG   OPS  Positions Teams
 ----+-----------------+--------+---+----+----+-----+----+-----+-----+----+----+---+---+----+---+----+---+---+---+---+----+---+-----+-----+-----+-----+---------+----------- 
    1 Jesse Barfield       716   241 1981 1992 21-32 1428  5394  4759  715 1219 216  30  551  49 1234  34  16  34 100   66  47  .256  .335  .466  .801 *9/8D7    TOR-TOT-NYY 
    2 Mickey Tettleton     732   245 1984 1997 23-36 1485  5745  4698  711 1132 210  16  949  72 1307  30  21  47  86   23  29  .241  .369  .449  .818 *2D39/7   OAK-BAL-DET-TEX 
    3 Rick Monday          775   241 1966 1984 20-38 1986  7162  6136  950 1619 248  64  924 107 1513  24  46  32  71   98  91  .264  .361  .443  .804 *89/73    KCA-OAK-CHC-LAD 
    4 Tony Clark           813   247 1995 2008 23-36 1523  5042  4466  622 1176 229  11  516  55 1185  21   0  39 130    6   9  .263  .340  .485  .825 *3D/7     DET-BOS-NYM-NYY-ARI-TOT 
    5 Jose Valentin        816   249 1992 2007 22-37 1678  6317  5539  872 1348 302  41  630  54 1294  29  70  49  66  136  56  .243  .321  .448  .769 *654/78D93 MIL-CHW-LAD-NYM 
    6 Mike Cameron         856   241 1995 2008 22-35 1680  6807  5896  935 1474 330  56  750  16 1642  80  29  52  93  289  79  .250  .340  .448  .788 *89/7D    CHW-CIN-SEA-NYM-SDP-MIL 
    7 Roy Campanella       856   242 1948 1957 26-35 1215  4816  4205  627 1161 178  18  533  30  501  30  30  18 143   25  15  .276  .360  .500  .860 *2        BRO         
    8 Adrian Beltre        862   242 1998 2008 19-29 1570  6400  5836  774 1581 321  26  459  54 1010  46  14  45 134   98  36  .271  .327  .459  .786 *5/D64    LAD-SEA     
    9 Aramis Ramirez       881   249 1998 2008 20-30 1328  5483  4957  686 1406 303  16  396  39  756  68   3  59 140   13  13  .284  .341  .502  .843 *5/D      PIT-TOT-CHC 
   10 Jeff Burroughs       882   240 1970 1985 19-34 1689  6449  5536  720 1443 230  20  831  65 1135  15   4  63 148   16  22  .261  .355  .439  .794 97D/3     WSA-TEX-ATL-SEA-OAK-TOR 
   11 Wally Berger         898   242 1930 1940 24-34 1350  5663  5163  809 1550 299  59  435   0  694  38  27   0  69   36   0  .300  .359  .522  .881 *87/39    BSN-TOT-CIN 
   12 Deron Johnson        923   245 1960 1976 21-37 1765  6620  5941  706 1447 247  33  585  54 1318  20  13  61 164   11  18  .244  .311  .420  .731 35D7/9    NYY-TOT-KCA-CIN-ATL-PHI-BOS 
   13 Dusty Baker         1013   242 1968 1986 19-37 2032  8021  7117  964 1981 320  23  762  52  926  30  27  85 158  137  73  .278  .347  .432  .779 *789/3D   ATL-LAD-SFG-OAK 
   14 Sal Bando           1039   242 1966 1981 22-37 2019  8288  7060  982 1790 289  38 1031  69  923  75  65  57 149   75  46  .254  .352  .408  .760 *5/D36471 KCA-OAK-MIL 
   15 Hack Wilson         1063   244 1923 1934 23-34 1348  5556  4760  884 1461 266  67  674   0  713  20 102   0  15   52   5  .307  .395  .545  .940 *879/4    NYG-CHC-BRO-TOT 
   16 Ken Singleton       1065   246 1970 1984 23-37 2078  8558  7189  985 2029 317  25 1263 125 1246  17  29  60 248   21  36  .282  .388  .436  .824 *9D7/8    NYM-MON-BAL 
   17 Bobby Abreu         1084   241 1996 2008 22-34 1799  7750  6490 1174 1946 454  53 1160  97 1405  29   6  65 119  318 103  .300  .405  .498  .903 *9/87D    HOU-PHI-TOT-NYY 
   18 Lou Whitaker        1084   244 1977 1995 20-38 2390  9967  8570 1386 2369 420  65 1197  79 1099  20  89  91 143  143  75  .276  .363  .426  .789 *4/D      DET         
   19 Cecil Cooper        1125   241 1971 1987 21-37 1896  7939  7349 1012 2192 415  47  448  79  911  17  46  79 150   89  49  .298  .337  .466  .803 *3D       BOS-MIL     
   20 Vern Stephens       1174   247 1941 1955 20-34 1720  7240  6497 1001 1859 307  42  692   0  685   6  37   8 169   25  22  .286  .355  .460  .815 *65/79    SLB-BOS-TOT-BAL 
   21 Roberto Clemente    1305   240 1955 1972 20-37 2433 10212  9454 1416 3000 440 166  621 167 1230  35  36  66 275   83  46  .317  .359  .475  .834 *9/8745   PIT         
   22 Ted Simmons         1389   248 1968 1988 18-38 2456  9685  8680 1074 2472 483  47  855 188  694  39  11 100 287   21  33  .285  .348  .437  .785 *2D3/759  STL-MIL-ATL 
   23 Goose Goslin        1609   248 1921 1938 20-37 2287  9822  8656 1483 2735 500 173  949   0  585  55 162   0   0  175  89  .316  .387  .500  .887 *79/835   WSH-TOT-SLB-WSH-DET 

Seasons/Careers found: 23.

 Photos from the George Grantham Bain Collection at the Library of Congress.